CNG vs Petrol Vs Diesel Cars - Which One Should You Opt For?

When buying a car, there's a rubric one considers in their quest to buy the perfect car. After factoring in all other features, the final decision-maker usually — after the price — is the cost efficiency, which is determined by the type of fuel the car will consume.

The type of fuel for a car also has a significant impact on its performance, running costs, and environmental impact. In India, the three most common fuel options for cars are compressed natural gas (CNG), petrol, and diesel. Each of these fuels has its advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice for you will depend on your specific needs and priorities. Whether you prefer mileage over performance or modern technology over seating capacity, we will be considering all of these aspects and help you make a decision.

In this article, we will compare CNG vs petrol vs diesel cars in terms of their performance, efficiency, cost, and environmental impact, to help you make an informed decision about which fuel option is best for your needs and preferences.

Parameters	Petrol Car	Diesel Car	CNG Car
Fuel Price	High	Lower than petrol	Low
Car Price	Most affordable	Most expensive	Expensive compared to petrol cars, cheaper than diesel cars.
Performance	It offers good performance with better pick-up than diesel and CNG cars.	Slower initial acceleration but offers good top-end performance.	Lower power output than petrol and diesel cars. Also, you may experience a slight lag in power delivery.
Comfort	Petrol engines are refined, and the NVH (Noise, Vibrations, Harshness) levels are low inside the car. Hence, they offer a comfortable driving experience.	Diesel engines are less refined than petrol. Hence, the NVH levels are higher inside the cabin.	Since CNG cars run on petrol-compatible engines, the refinement is on par with petrol cars.
Boot Space	Spacious	Spacious	Not ideal, CNG takes up most of the boot space
Mileage	Lower than CNG and diesel cars.	Higher than petrol cars, but lower than CNG cars.	Higher than petrol and diesel cars.
Running costs	High	Lower than petrol cars, but higher than CNG cars.	Low
Maintenance costs	Higher than CNG cars but lower than diesel cars.	High	Highest due to the CNG kit.
Environmental friendliness	It is not environment-friendly as exhaust gas comprises carbon monoxide.	It produces carbon emissions.	They are environment-friendly as the fuel is completely combustible and produces clean emissions.
Fuel availability	Easily available	Easily available	CNG fuel stations are difficult to access and find.
Engine life	Lower than diesel engines.	Increased life compared to petrol engines.	The engine life is similar to petrol engines.

Performance

One of the primary considerations when choosing a fuel type is its performance. When considering CNG vs petrol vs diesel, in terms of acceleration and power, petrol cars tend to have the best performance, followed by diesel cars. CNG cars, on the other hand, generally have lower power and acceleration compared to petrol and diesel cars. This is because CNG engines are typically smaller and less powerful than petrol/diesel engines, and CNG has a lower energy density than petrol/diesel. However, CNG cars can still provide satisfactory performance for everyday driving needs, and their lower power levels may also make them easier to handle for some drivers.

For petrol vs diesel, petrol comes out on top. So if you want a car that gives you the best acceleration and power possible, you should opt for a petrol car. This is followed by diesel cars which don't give the same power and acceleration as petrol cars but are still very good and strong. And the third is CNG cars, which give lower acceleration and can be a bit difficult to maneuver on inclined and hilly terrain.

Performance: Petrol > Diesel > CNG

Read More – CNG Kit Price in India – CNG Conversion Kit Brands, Prices, Performance, Features

Efficiency

Fuel efficiency is another important factor to consider when choosing the fuel type. In general, diesel cars tend to be the most fuel-efficient, followed by CNG cars and then petrol cars. This is because diesel has a higher energy density than petrol or CNG, which means that it can generate more power per unit of fuel. Diesel engines are also typically more efficient than petrol engines, as they have a higher compression ratio and can operate at a higher thermal efficiency. CNG cars, on the other hand, have a lower energy density than petrol/diesel, but their engines are generally more efficient than petrol engines due to their higher compression ratio and operate at a lower temperature. So, CNG cars can often achieve similar fuel efficiency to petrol cars while emitting fewer greenhouse gases.

By efficiency, we mean mileage, and CNG vs petrol vs diesel mileage is an important factor to consider. Diesel cars are thus far the most efficient as they give higher mileage (kilometres per litre). Following them are CNG cars which are then followed by petrol cars which, despite their performance, use a lot of fuel and aren't that efficient.

Efficiency: Diesel > CNG > Petrol

Cost

The cost of fuel is another important factor when choosing a car. In India, CNG is generally the cheapest fuel option, followed by diesel and then petrol. This is because CNG is a domestically produced fuel that is cheaper to produce and distribute than petrol/diesel. Diesel is also generally cheaper than petrol, although the price gap between diesel vs petrol has been decreasing in recent years. In terms of running costs, CNG cars tend to be cheaper to operate than petrol/diesel cars, as they have lower fuel costs and may also have lower maintenance costs. However, it's worth noting that CNG cars may have higher upfront costs, as they require special equipment and modifications to run on CNG.

Cost efficiency: CNG > Diesel > Petrol

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of fuel is another important factor to consider when choosing a car. In terms of greenhouse gas emissions, CNG is generally the cleanest fuel option, followed by petrol and then diesel. CNG is a clean-burning fuel that emits fewer greenhouse gases than petrol/diesel when combusted. Petrol is also a relatively clean-burning fuel, although it does produce more greenhouse gases than CNG. Diesel, on the other hand, produces more greenhouse gases than petrol or CNG, as it has a higher carbon content and produces more particulate matter when combusted. Do note, however, that the specific emissions of a car will depend on a variety of factors, including the efficiency of the engine and the age of the vehicle.

So in terms of the environmental impact of CNG vs petrol vs diesel, CNG is the cleanest fuel among the three, followed by petrol and then diesel.

Environmental Impact: CNG > Petrol > Diesel

Read More - Petrol vs Diesel Cars Working Explained

Choose between CNG vs Petrol vs Diesel

Every person has different needs in their life. Some use their car for travelling long distances daily while others might hardly use it. Some people may need a bigger car type, like an SUV for larger families, while others may need a small hatchback for a smaller family.

With this information in mind, we should ask ourselves which fuel type would suit us the best. When it comes to choosing CNG vs petrol vs diesel variants for your car, it's important to consider your specific needs and priorities. Here are some questions that you should ask yourself before making a decision:

1. What is your primary use for the car?

This is an important consideration, as it will determine the fuel efficiency you aim for and, thus, the type of engine most suitable for you. If you will be using the car primarily for long-distance driving or towing, diesel or petrol may be the better option. On the other hand, if you will be using the car mostly for short-distance commuting, CNG or petrol may be a better choice.

2. How important is fuel efficiency to you?

Fuel efficiency is an important factor to consider when selecting a fuel type, as it can have a significant impact on your running costs. If fuel efficiency is a top priority, diesel or CNG may be the best choice, as they tend to be more fuel-efficient than petrol. Diesel engines are usually more efficient than petrol engines, and CNG engines are also generally more efficient than petrol engines.

3. What is your budget?

The cost of fuel is another important factor. In India, CNG is generally the cheapest fuel option, followed by diesel and then petrol. This is because CNG is a domestically produced fuel that is cheaper to produce and distribute than petrol/diesel. Diesel is also generally cheaper than petrol, although the price gap between the two fuels has been decreasing in recent years.

4. How important is your environmental impact to you?

The environmental impact of fuel is another important factor to consider when selecting the fuel type. In terms of greenhouse gas emissions, CNG is generally the cleanest fuel option, followed by petrol and then diesel. CNG is a clean-burning fuel that emits fewer greenhouse gases than petrol/diesel when combusted. If you are concerned about the environmental impact of your fuel choice, CNG may be the best option for you.

5. Are you willing to make any sacrifices in terms of performance or convenience?

CNG cars generally have lower power and acceleration than petrol/diesel cars, and they may also have a limited range compared to petrol/diesel cars. If you are willing to make some sacrifices in terms of performance or convenience to save on fuel costs or reduce your environmental impact, CNG may be a good choice for you. On the other hand, if you prioritize performance and convenience and are willing to pay more for fuel, petrol/diesel may be a better choice.

Read More - CNG Car Long-Run Maintenance Guide

Conclusion

From the data given above, we can deduce many things about the various fuel types: CNG vs Petrol vs Diesel. CNG is the cheapest, most environmentally conscious, and most efficient fuel type and can cover large distances easily. It has the lowest acceleration and power among the three and has a high maintenance cost. On the other hand, petrol is the most expensive fuel type and lies between CNG and diesel in terms of fuel efficiency, while diesel is the least efficient fuel type and is cheaper than petrol.

FAQs