BMW X1 vs Audi Q3: Which Used Luxury SUV Offers Better Value?

If you are in the market for a premium second hand SUV under ₹30 lakh in 2025, chances are the used BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 will likely be on your shortlist. Both are starting points into German premium ownership, both have strong badge pull, and are widely available in the used market.

But choosing between the two is not just about which listing seems tempting, it's about how they compare on costs, features, driving experience, and overall value. Keep scrolling as we’re about to put both these models against each other for a better comparison. 

BMW X1 vs Audi Q3: Specs & Dimensions (2020 models)

Here is a side-by-side comparison of both the German SUVs for their 2020 trims: 

Takeaway:

• The second hand BMW X1 is the winner here in terms of boot practicality and feels more nimble on the road.
• The second hand Audi Q3 offers Quattro AWD in some trims, a slightly wider stance and a more planted feel.

Running Costs: BMW X1 vs Audi Q3

Luxury cars are expensive to maintain, but knowing where each model cuts costs makes it easier for buyers to budget better. Here's how the used BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 compare:

In both cases, it is realistic to expect budgeting ₹25,000–₹50,000 annually plus a ₹1–1.5 lakh buffer for unexpected expenses. Both SUVs can also be found with prepaid service packs, which reduce surprises. 

Used Car Prices in 2025

The used BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 debate only makes sense if you are aware of how both depreciate.

BMW X1 (second hand BMW X1):

• 2015–2017: ₹6–15 lakh, usually higher mileage and older interiors.
• 2018–2019: ₹18–28 lakh, sweet spot for budget-conscious buyers.
• 2019–2021: ₹20–30 lakh, combines fresher styling and modern features at sensible prices.
• 2022–2024: ₹35–40 lakh, warranty-backed but discounts over new are thinner.

Audi Q3 (second hand Audi Q3):

• 2015–2017: ₹6–15 lakh, mostly diesels with ageing interiors.
• 2018–2020: ₹18–28 lakh, the final first-gen Q3s in India, which are great for value.
• 2022–2024: ₹38–45 lakh, nearly new, warranty intact, but value gap vs fresh stock is smaller.

Driving Feel: BMW X1 vs Audi Q3

The used BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 debate is not just about numbers, it's also about how you feel from the driver's seat.

• BMW X1 (second hand BMW X1):
  • Tighter steering and firmer suspension give it a sportier edge.
  • Run-flat tyres sharpen handling with very little body roll.
  • Feels more “driver-first,” especially appealing to younger buyers.
     
• Audi Q3 (second hand Audi Q3):
  • Softer, comfort-tuned suspension makes it smoother in the city.
  • Cabin insulation is better, translating to quieter drives.
  • Quattro AWD on select trims boosts confidence on highways and hills.

Choose the X1 if you prefer a dynamic driving experience, choose the Q3 if you prefer slightly more comfort and refinement.

Interiors & Features

Inside, the difference is just as clear.

• BMW X1:
  • Clean and practical driver-focused cabin.
  • Practical layout with 505L boot space, making it family-friendly.
  • Dynamic interior with better materials.
     
• Audi Q3:
  • High-quality interiors, but can feel dated. 
  • Quieter cabin.
  • Better rear shoulder room.

Both deliver on the essentials, but the X1 wins on practicality here. 

Resale Value: Which Holds Better?

Resale is where many buyers tilt one way or the other. Well, they both are luxury cars which tend to lose value quicker and they both depreciate at more or less the same pace. You can expect 5-year-old examples usually falling between the ₹25 to ₹30 lakh bracket. Both brands also have buyback programmes, but trusted platforms such as CARS24 can provide you with even better pricing when you plan to let go. 

Who Should Buy Which SUV?

• Pick a pre-owned BMW X1 if:
  • You prioritise driving feel and sharper handling.
  • Practicality (boot space, city manoeuvrability) matters.
  • You want more choices in the used market.
     
• Pick a second hand Audi Q3 if:
  • You want a quieter cabin. 
  • You want lighter steering.
  • You want petrol models with stronger demand in metros.

Summary

In the BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 debate, there's no clear winner: it's a matter of your priorities. The second hand BMW X1 offers sportier handling and practical space and is the value-driven driver’s choice. The second hand Audi Q3, however, is a more refined and quieter car, making it a better choice for comfort seekers and city professionals. 

Routine upkeep averages at around ₹25,000 to 50,000 for both, with occasional bills crossing ₹1 lakh. Users can target 5 to 7-year-old models to get the best value, features, and depreciation. Whether you're planning to buy a pre-owned BMW X1 or a second hand Audi Q3, CARS24 provides verified records, inspection-backed listings, and fair pricing, ensuring you enter the world of German SUV ownership with confidence.